Back to all articles
    Equipment Review

    Friendship 729 Battle 2 Orange Sponge, Provincial Blue Sponge & Neo Review: Still a Great No-Boost Hurricane Alternative

    Victor
    28 min read
    729 Battle 2 Orange Sponge, Provincial Blue Sponge and Neo rubbers
    Friendship 729 Battle 2 Orange Sponge, Provincial Blue Sponge and Neo rubbers

    The Orange Sponge is the easiest and most controlled of the three for amateurs but also the least dangerous, the Provincial Blue Sponge behaves the most like a boosted DHS Hurricane 3 Neo with only a bit less spin and speed but a low throw that demands solid technique, and the Neo is a mix between the two that gives away too much spin and short game to find its place

    A long time ago, when I was stuck in the lowest regional divisions and didn't even know how to open with my backhand, I decided that it would be a great idea to stop boosting my Hurricanes and just play with something easier to prepare and handle, so I got the Friendship 729 Battle 2 Provincial (and the normal version) and played with those for a little while. This was probably sometime in 2021 or so, and already back then, the Battle 2 was acknowledged as one of the best (if not the best) no-boost alternatives to the DHS Hurricane 3 (Neo).

    That was, and still is, a big deal, as we all know how much of a hassle it is to boost your rubbers periodically: it costs time and money, it's not always 100% the same, the performance degrades faster than with other rubbers, etc. So for a rubber to promise you the same spin and speed as the best Chinese rubber in the market without all that hassle and for a fraction of the price, it is quite the big thing, and something that most of the rubbers I've tested cannot actually achieve.

    Fast forward to today, and since the Battle 2 left me with a great experience back then, I decided to go back to the good old times and test some of the most popular Battle 2 versions to tell you as many details as I possibly can about the Friendship 729 Battle 2, and why I think that it still is a great no-boost amateur-friendly alternative to the powerful Hurricane 3 Neo.

    And to make this review even sweeter, I am not going to review one, nor two, but three rubbers this time! So you really get a full picture of the most common Battle 2 options out there and see which one you like the most (sorry Golden and National users, I didn't have the time for it!).

    As per usual, I like giving you a bit of a sneak peek before we start, and for this time I'm going to keep it nice and simple: the orange sponge Battle 2 feels like a not-too-boosted Hurricane 3 Neo orange sponge and it's the friendliest of the three for us amateurs, the blue sponge provincial Battle 2 is the closest that I have tested so far to a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo blue sponge but it's also pretty demanding, and the newer Battle 2 Neo is somewhere in between but I don't think it is worth buying considering that the other two serve a better purpose in my opinion.

    Right, so that was the intro, and with three rubbers this is going to be a long one, so grab a drink and a snack (maybe a soda and some nuts this time? haha) and let's get into the review!

    Side note: As I mentioned, the Battle 2 also comes in other versions (i.e. the National and the Gold), but since I have not tested them myself, I will not comment any further on those.

    The TL;DR: Battle 2 Orange Sponge, Provincial Blue Sponge & Neo

    CategoryBattle 2 Orange SpongeBattle 2 Provincial Blue SpongeBattle 2 Neo Blue Sponge
    Weight49g (39 degrees) cut to the B2X, light for being a dense Chinese rubberAround 48.5g (39 degrees) cut to the B2X, also not heavy for this kind of no-boost rubber47g (39 degrees) cut to the B2X, lightest of the three
    Sponge & TopsheetSoftest feel of the three rubbers, very tacky, really smellyHarder sponge and very tacky, best for ball holding and dwellFeels softer but plays harder, ball sinks in less, lowest dwell
    Speed & ControlLeast speed of the three and many gears, best balance and controlMany gears, very linear, most power, close to a boosted H3N blue sponge, lots of controlSimilar speed to the orange, catapult does the work, least balance and control
    Spin potentialIn between, clearly more than the Neo, less than the ProvincialThe most of the three, a bit less than boosted H3N but still a lot of spinWay less spin than the other two, it was the main disappointing area of this rubber
    Throw angleHighest of the three but still not high, medium at bestLower than the orange sponge, similar to Neo, it makes it demandingSimilar to the provincial in practice, but higher in theory
    Drives & LoopsEasiest to open with and to control when going hard, least dangerousEasy to drive, openings are not easy like with H3N blue sponge, good counterloopsBest for counterloops together with the provincial, least control but speedy
    ServesVery good and spinny, in betweenAlmost like H3N, best of the three clearlyNot good, it was a struggle to create spin
    FlicksEasiest for me due to the higher throw and softer feelMost controlled overall, easiest for my training partner, not for meMost powerful flicks but with the least control of the three
    PushesA bit less good than the provincialExcellent, low, short and dead, really goodWorst, balls tend to pop up or go long
    BlocksVery safe blocking, probably safestVery safe passive blocks like H3NA bit less good than the other two
    Flat hitsMore forgiving on hard smash ballsNot made for it, you need to add spin to itEasier to hit it harder but risky to do so
    BoostingNot boosted, not needed for meNot boosted, one layer could be fineNot boosted, could have a bit but careful
    Price & Durability30 euros, very durable and cheap25-30 euros, very cheap and durable too25-30 euros, topsheet degraded already

    The technicalities

    Starting with the Provincial Blue Sponge, it really looks and feels like a DHS Hurricane 3 Neo when you take it out of the package: a hard blue sponge (39 degrees on the Chinese scale in my case), a hard topsheet that is very tacky compared to most of the rubbers you buy nowadays, and it comes out of the box pretty curled, which is typical Chinese no-boost rubber stuff. It also has a very big smell, and I mean very big, it kept smelling for days, so if you store your rackets in your bedroom or your car, you have been warned haha. Out of the package it was 67g and cut to my B2X it was 48.5g, pretty light for a 'boosted' rubber.

    The Orange Sponge is what I would call the traditional Battle 2, and it was 69g out of the package, was very smelly and curled as well, and ended up weighing 49g on the B2X, also very light for this type of rubber. The biggest difference with the blue one is in the sponge, which feels clearly softer (more on that in the next section), and that softer sponge is in my opinion the reason why it plays like it plays.

    The Neo is the newest of the three, and it was 66g uncut, also terribly smelly and fairly curled inwards, slightly less tacky and ended up being 47g cut to the B2X. It is also the odd one of the three, because the sponge feels softer than the Provincial Blue Sponge, and yet it plays and feels harder, but I'll explain that one properly in Sponge & Topsheet feeling because it's the key to understanding this rubber.

    One last thing is that the quality control on the Neo was better than on the other two, where I found some holes in the sponges and some loose topsheet at the edges of the rubbers. Probably something random but I wanted to mention it here so you are aware of this. In the end they are very cheap, so I'm fine with that.

    How I tested the Battle 2s

    I first played the Provincial Blue Sponge a little bit on the DHS Wang Chuqin (and originally on a Viscaria years ago) and then also on my DHS Fang Bo B2X, and in the end all three rubbers were tested on the B2X (fast and lower throwing by nature, so keep that in mind when you read the Throw angle section), always on the forehand and in both training and matches.

    None of them were boosted, and that was on purpose, because the whole point of the Battle 2 is that you don't need to boost it, so I wanted the real no-boost experience that most of you will get when you glue it straight out of the package.

    Do keep in mind that I play boosted Hurricanes on my forehand though, so a lot of what follows is compared to a boosted blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo, which is my reference (and also the rubber most of you are probably comparing the Battle 2 with).

    And this time I also had somebody to help me for the final verdict, as on the last day of testing my good friend Tony from the club also played with all three of them, and his impressions were really interesting, I will add them here and there so you have two voices to compare, we don't always agree on everything, as feeling varies per person and technique.

    As a side note, Tony is slightly better than me, plays at the second highest regional level too (can soon play the highest I'm sure) and is a looper like me, with Hurricanes on both sides although he also briefly played with the YuanJian Zhantian on his backhand. He still plays with the Lin Gaoyuan blade, which is similar to my B2X. He liked all three rubbers from their own perspective, but his favourite was clearly the Orange Sponge and his least favourite the Neo, and the sets we played tell the story quite well: with the Neo he lost his set badly, and with the Orange Sponge he won his set (more on the why in the sections below).

    But anyways, to wrap up this section, the testing period was about 5-6 weeks, ending with that last session together with Tony to compare all three side by side.

    The Battle 2s in depth

    Sponge & Topsheet feeling

    The Orange Sponge has the softest feel of the three when you play it, the ball sinks into the sponge more easily and the whole rubber feels a bit calmer than the blue one. It's still a Chinese tacky rubber, so don't expect a tensor feeling here, but together with the relatively higher throw and shorter flight distance (read: less catapult) it gives you that extra safety margin that the other two don't really give you. Tony also found it easier on the body, so that's a plus point for those of us who are not built like a Chinese provincial team player haha.

    The Provincial Blue Sponge is just like a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo blue sponge, and both Tony and I agreed that it's the one that feels and behaves the most like one. In the beginning, it feels harder than the other two, but funnily enough, you can actually penetrate the sponge more than with the Neo. The topsheet is hard as well, but it grips much better than the Sanwei Target National on thin brushes and I think it also deforms and wraps way better (at least that's my feeling).

    And then the Neo, which is the odd one. The sponge feels softer than the Provincial Blue Sponge, but because of the added catapult it has, it actually feels harder when you play with it, as the ball penetrates less into the sponge and is gone rather quickly. The dwell time is lower and you need to do less with your body because the catapult does it for you, and you can also hit it more easily, it needs less brushing. That sounds great on paper, but as you will see in pretty much every section that follows, it comes with a couple important tradeoffs that neither Tony nor I enjoyed as much.

    So in short, the Orange Sponge is focused on balance and control, the Provincial Blue Sponge is focused on giving you the boosted Hurricane feeling without the booster, and the Neo is focused on an easier 'free' catapult. That's also how they play and the summary of this whole review in one sentence ;)

    Speed & Control

    Starting with the Orange Sponge, it has the least overall speed of the three (while still having a lot of gears), but not by a huge margin (the speed is not that much lower than the Neo), and in exchange you get much more control and a better balance overall, which I really enjoyed. Tony put it very nicely during our last session, you can still play it hard like you would with the Neo, there is less power, yes, but the ball goes on the table, and I guess that's also why he won his set against me with it. As he said (and I fully agree), in a real match you don't always go hard, and for most of us amateurs that's exactly why the extra control is worth more than a couple of extra km/h in my opinion.

    The Provincial Blue Sponge on the other hand, has the most gears of the three, as many as a Hurricane 3 Neo boosted with 1-2 layers or so, and it's very linear, so it can do it all. It doesn't reach the maximum power of a blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo with a national booster and 2-4 layers, but the speed is similar to a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo (a bit slower), and definitely faster and more reactive than an unboosted Hurricane 3 Neo, both orange and blue sponge. There is a lot of control thanks to the linearity and the gears, you can brush it thin and you can hit it thick, it's always very predictable and gives you the feeling that you are in control. But (and this is a big but) it really needs the Chinese hit-brush technique, body commitment and physique, otherwise it won't work (think opening heavy backspin with a blue sponge Hurricane and then you know what I mean with solid technique, footwork and physical condition). The lack of control only comes from its spin sensitivity and the very low throw, that's its only real problem.

    Compared to the other two, the Provincial Blue Sponge gives you more control, more spin and more power than the Neo, and it's harder to control than the Orange Sponge but with more potential. So it's the best of the three for power, spin and speed, and also the most difficult one to master in my opinion, which makes it the one for the higher level players (the same story as with the orange and blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo, really).

    And then the Neo, where the speed is similar to the Orange Sponge and a bit less than the Provincial Blue Sponge, and the gears are the least of the three because it starts higher and reaches less speed at the end than the Provincial Blue Sponge. This does mean that with the Neo you need to use your body less, as the catapult does more of that work for you, but that comes with a control tradeoff and also way less spin. In the end, the Neo has the least balance of all three and for me it felt more difficult to use normally, I just didn't feel comfortable with it.

    For me, the Neo is the least forgiving of the three and even less forgiving than a boosted blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo, but not because it is so powerful or so bouncy like other rubbers, but because the balance just feels off between speed (related to dwell) and spin, so you end up forcing your technique to adjust to what the rubber wants, and I don't like that (more on that later).

    The last important thing that I will mention is that with all three Battle 2s it is easier to get that metallic 'click' feeling than with a boosted blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo. With the Hurricane you need to do more to hear the click and it's more demanding on the body, but only a bit more than with the Provincial Blue Sponge.

    So in summary, if control is what you are after, the Orange Sponge is the one, if you want the boosted blue sponge Hurricane experience without the booster bottle, the Provincial Blue Sponge is the one, and the Neo is a mix of the two that I wouldn't go for.

    Spin & Grip

    The Orange Sponge sits in between the other two rubbers for spin, clearly behind the Provincial Blue Sponge but also clearly ahead of the Neo. That was very noticeable in all games I played with the three rubbers, as the Orange Sponge simply had much more spin than the Neo while not being that much slower. Compared to a boosted blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo it's further away in spin generation than the Provincial Blue Sponge, so don't expect the full Hurricane spin here.

    The Provincial Blue Sponge, on the other hand, has a huge grip and huge spin, less than a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo but still a ton of spin, and Tony and I both agreed it has more grip than the other two. It has a bit less grip and spin than the Hurricane, but it's close (closer than the other two Battle 2s for sure). It feels like a rubber from the past, which is exactly what it is, focused more on spin and less on speed and liveliness compared to the modern rubbers, just a classic Chinese tacky rubber, so the grip is very good. When it got humid it also held up pretty decently, not like the Sanwei Target National that starts slipping when humid, and overall I had much better grip than with the Sanwei Target National, so much more confidence in my strokes.

    And then the Neo, which for sure has less spin than both the Provincial Blue Sponge and the Orange Sponge, and it's not a small difference either. It also has way less grip, which you feel the most in the short and touch game because I feel like the ball sinks in less and the dwell time is lower, so the rubber simply has less time to grab the ball and put rotation on it, and that's the price to pay for the added catapult it has.

    So yeah, if spin is your main weapon, the Provincial Blue Sponge is the clear winner here, the Orange Sponge is a very decent second, and the Neo is a big step down, so keep that in mind.

    Throw angle

    The Orange Sponge is the one with the highest throw for me (think medium-ish throw when compared to any ESN rubbers), and that was for me a big part of why it felt like the easiest to handle of the three. You get a bit more arc and safety over the net without having to load your whole body for it, and Tony also mentioned that its throw angle was one of the reasons he had more control with it. I will also add that the flight distance felt a bit more comfortable than with the other two, and even though it was more on the long side (medium-long ish), it felt just right to me, like with those other rubbers that always make you feel confident in your shots.

    The Provincial Blue Sponge is a different story, its throw angle is clearly lower and that is also the only real problem of this rubber. It would be almost perfect if the throw was a bit more like a boosted blue sponge Hurricane, but it isn't, so I feel like you need a flexier blade and your technique needs to make more of the arc, with your whole body making up for it, just like the old Chinese tacky rubbers used to be (which is tough as you get older). So nowadays, as the game gets faster and the backhand becomes more dominant, it's a bit less attractive to use this rubber in my opinion, as you lose relatively more time loading and charging, and in fast rallies this is important. On a positive note, the flight distance is comfortably long, so there is good control there even though the speed is present.

    And then the Neo, where in theory the throw should be higher, but Tony and I found it very similar to the Provincial Blue Sponge, probably because of the lower dwell and the extra initial speed, so there is less time to make the arc. The flight distance also felt longer due to that, and overall it just felt less comfortable than the other two.

    Drives & Loops

    Driving first, the Orange Sponge feels very comfortable when warming up and doing normal drives, and you feel like the throw and flight distance are just fine. With the Provincial Blue Sponge you do already feel the lower throw but not that much, and it has that very nice clicky boosted feeling when activating the sponge. The Neo also has that but a bit less, and when driving, the Neo feels a bit more like the Orange Sponge.

    The normal topspin loops are where you will start feeling the differences though. The Orange Sponge is the one that gives you the most control and safety, very rarely my normal warmup topspin loops did not end up on the table, and during games, it is more forgiving on poor technique and footwork, that's for sure. It's also quicker to forgive the wrong hit-brush ratio, so you have to worry less about that.

    However, this is not the case with the Provincial Blue Sponge, as here is where the low throw kicks in. It's not that it's difficult if you are used to the Hurricane blue sponge, but it's also not that easy, the rubber wants you to do things right (body included, very important to stay low) and half-baked loops, or stopping or holding back power, get punished. If you do everything correctly though, there is a lot of power and spin and a lot of danger for the opponent. A boosted Hurricane 3 Neo is slightly safer here, with a better feeling and more margin for errors and wrong technique, so that's the price of not having to boost.

    And then the Neo, which Tony described as a 'just go hard' rubber, and that's pretty much it, I cannot put it in better words. When you hit it hard, you can activate the sponge more, and you also get more dwell, arc and control with a lot of speed, but the tradeoff is the spin and the fact that you have to go hard on each ball, which is exhausting and gives me a casino feeling, in all hands I must go all-in for it to behave like I want it to.

    This is directly related to opening backspin balls, where the Neo also shows this character. With the Neo, you can hit the ball really hard and it often lands on the other side of the table, but if you don't, it's actually the most frustrating of the three, and you will miss a lot. This really reminded me of the Xiom Vega China, a rubber that behaves exactly like this too.

    Fortunately, the Orange Sponge was much easier to handle, and opening backspin balls was a pleasure with it, you had many more choices here and depending on the situation you could do a thin brush or a proper hit-brush if the incoming spin was not so heavy. The opponent will have an easier time dealing with them though, but you can often get the initiative first.

    And regarding the Provincial Blue Sponge, for me it was the second easiest to open with, but here you also see the main disadvantage of this rubber, as loops against very heavy backspin are not easy to perform, like with a blue sponge Hurricane. You need the hit-brush, the lower body and leg lift, the correct racket angle and contact moment, so the safety margin is not very big, and even though you get a great feeling when it works, it demands correct technique even more than the normal loops. That's one of the bigger differences with a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo, where opening feels a bit easier if you use the correct technique, because the fresh booster gives you that extra dwell, throw angle and margin basically.

    Finally when counterlooping, I felt like the Orange Sponge was fine and predictable, just what I would have expected, but it was of course better with the Provincial Blue Sponge, it really shined there, and for me it was one of the biggest strengths of the rubber. Counterlooping Chinese style was super easy and sort of on autopilot, and it gave me the confidence to just do it more, as the throw, the tackiness and the whole rubber and topsheet work together to bring a lot of balls back on the table with a lot of danger. It's pretty similar to a blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo, for me almost the same, with the Hurricane being a bit safer and with a bit more power, but also more expensive. Funnily enough, Tony found counterlooping a bit more difficult with the Provincial Blue Sponge, while I found it easier to control (so maybe it's also a matter of taste here). Tony actually liked the Neo more for counterlooping, as he needed to do less with his body and could go through it more.

    So to summarise this section, the Orange Sponge is still the safest choice for drives and loops, the Provincial Blue Sponge is in the category of higher risk and higher reward and pays off if your technique is solid, and the Neo is a bit all or nothing, so that's the tradeoff right there.

    Serves

    Serving follows exactly the same ranking as the spin section which was to be expected: the Provincial Blue Sponge is the best of the three, the Orange Sponge is in between, and the Neo is clearly the worst.

    So basically the Orange Sponge gives you a lot of spin, more than most of the ESN hybrids, but it is not at the same level as a boosted Hurricane 3 Neo blue sponge, and also gives you less than the Battle 2 Provincial Blue Sponge. This likely comes from the amount of grip that the three rubbers have, and with the Orange I felt like the sponge was releasing the ball a bit faster than with the Provincial, so you get a bit less spin.

    This early release mechanism was very clear with the Neo, where for both me and Tony it was really difficult to keep the ball short and spinny, something that you can easily do with the Provincial Blue Sponge. It's a pity that the Neo was just a disappointment when it comes to serving, it is a very important advantage of a hard tacky Chinese rubber and I feel like with the Neo you totally lose that.

    In any case, the star of the show when serving was the Provincial Blue Sponge, as its serves are just like a Hurricane 3 Neo really, the tackiness, the hard (but ball-grabbing) topsheet and the linear sponge do the job, and there is a lot of friction power and grip, so a lot of spin on forehand serves. I could often get a lot of direct points with my pendulum serve, and for me this was not such a big difference compared to the normal boosted Hurricane 3 Neo.

    Flicks

    Forehand flicks are another shot where Tony and I did not really agree on the ranking, but at least we did agree on one thing, the Neo is the most difficult of the three to flick with, it has the most power sure, but it is again hard to control due to the lower dwell, faster release, and really flat trajectory (the ball doesn't have time to arc), surely this won't be a surprise if you read the other sections in this article.

    Anyways, for me the Orange Sponge was the easiest to flick with, because of the higher throw, the lower speed and the softer feel, and Tony had it in between.

    The Provincial Blue Sponge was the easiest to flick with for Tony and the most controlled one overall, and even though the low throw definitely does not make it easy, it has a lot of grip and dwell, so I can agree with him, and for me it was more or less as easy as the Orange Sponge (a very small difference, if any).

    Pushes

    Pushing is always related to serving, and it is not going to be an exception here, so everything I mentioned in serving also applies here.

    This means that the Orange Sponge pushes very decently and it sits in between the other two for grip and control, but it doesn't reach the level of the Provincial Blue Sponge.

    That is because the Provincial Blue Sponge is a pushing machine, you have a lot of grip, dwell and control, and it even works great for chopping! Tony chops a lot on his forehand when he needs to defend far from the table, he does this with a fast carbon blade and his blue sponge Hurricane, so he knows what he is doing, and those chops come back very loaded. So with the Battle 2 this was pretty much the same! Big plus for control players if you have this type of shot!

    So yeah, the Provincial is a lot of fun to defend with, there is no catapult, and you can drop the ball where you want, low, short and dead. The best player from our club's youth team (who plays in the second Dutch national division) commented that he didn't expect my pushes to be so low, short and dangerous, and that's something I definitely cannot do with the Sanwei Target National or the Xiom Vega China.

    Finally the Neo, it was again a disappointment in this area, the balls popped up much more and went longer compared to the other two, and there clearly was less grip and control. Tony found pushing with it very bad and I get it, the catapult that helps you on the big shots works against you on the short ones, so if your short game matters to you (and it should), this is a big minus point.

    Blocks

    I will keep the blocking section shorter, because all three rubbers were good for blocking, similar to a normal Chinese tacky rubber for blocking, and even though the Neo was a bit harder for this due to the catapult, it was definitely much much easier than with a Dignics 09c for example.

    If I had to choose which one was better for blocking, I'd probably go with the Orange Sponge because it has less of that speedy feeling, but blocking with the Provincial Blue Sponge was also very safe, its passive blocks were just like on a Hurricane 3 Neo, as the catapult didn't kick in and you could hold and defend very easily.

    So yeah, all three rubbers are good for blocking, nothing to say against that.

    Flat hits & counterhits

    None of the Battle 2s are rubbers made for flat hitting and counterhits or counterdrives, but there are some minor differences between them, so it's worth mentioning here.

    I'd say that the Neo is the best at flat hitting, and as I mentioned above, it felt a bit like the Xiom Vega China where you could just hit it hard and the rubber would do the work for you, no need to add the brushing part that the Hurricanes always need in order for them to work. So yes, the Neo would be the best for this type of shot even though I would still not recommend it for blockers and flat-hitters.

    Regarding the other two, the Orange Sponge is probably the more forgiving one of the two, as the Provincial is not made for flat hitting and it's actually pretty bad at it, but that is fine, it's simply not the rubber's philosophy (it's a loopers rubber focused on spin first).

    Boosting

    Boosting is probably one of the reasons that brought you to this article, as I'm sure you can also appreciate a rubber that plays like a Hurricane but without the good old oil!

    However, let me disappoint you a little bit here, as for this review I wanted the purest experience only, and I did not boost any of the Battle 2s, I really wanted to see if the no-boost claims could still hold nowadays (after so many years) and how the rubbers would play with the new blades and balls.

    And what I can say about this experience is that I still believe that you don't need to boost any of the three, I personally would not use the Neo anyways (boosted or unboosted), but I will keep both of the other 2 (Orange and Provincial) for a longer time because they play absolutely great without the booster, especially after the first couple sessions when the rubber is broken-in.

    But in case you are considering boosting them to accelerate the break-in period and to refresh the rubbers a bit (sometimes they are a bit old even when new), then I'd say give them a thin layer only, and ideally Seamoon or any other Chinese booster, the sponge feels like it will enjoy that more than other boosters, as these are your typical Chinese hard and dense sponges, just like with the Hurricanes. So yeah, in my opinion, they won't be nice if you overboost, and I say this because many years ago I boosted my Provincial twice and did not like that experience, it was sort of 'agitated' like the Neo, and I prefer a linear experience when playing hard and tacky rubbers.

    Price & Durability

    This is perhaps my favourite section of the whole review, because for the price you can get the Battle 2 for nowadays, it's still a total steal!

    If you manage to get either the Orange Sponge or the Provincial Blue Sponge for 25 euros on AliExpress and they last you, let's say 6 months easily, then for the performance you get and the price and durability they have, it's a fantastic deal, nothing else for me to add there!

    I think that's why this rubber has remained so popular in the world and is still the reference answer when people ask for a budget no-boost Hurricane alternative.

    One last thing on the durability, I will add a photo below so you can see it but the Neo topsheet has degraded faster and more clearly than the other two (performance is not affected that much though yet), so I wanted to mention that, as I think the Neo will likely last a bit less, probably 4-6 months max, whole the others will likely go more towards the 6-9 month timeframe.

    Worn topsheet of the 729 Battle 2 Neo after the test period
    Worn topsheet of the 729 Battle 2 Neo after the test period

    So who are these rubbers for?

    I think that you will enjoy the Battle 2 Orange Sponge if:

    • You are an amateur who wants the classic Chinese tacky experience without having to boost, and you want the most control and margin of the Battle 2s.
    • You want the easiest of the three for opening against backspin (and for me also for flicking), and you are fine with those shots being a bit less dangerous.
    • You want something easier on the body, and you don't need the last bit of spin and power of the Provincial Blue Sponge.

    And you will prefer the Battle 2 Provincial Blue Sponge if:

    • You want the closest thing to a boosted blue sponge Hurricane 3 Neo without boosting, behaving very similarly with only a bit less spin and speed (and perhaps being a bit less demanding on the body).
    • You have solid Chinese hit-brush technique and the body commitment and physique to go with it, which makes it the best of the three for the higher level players.
    • Your serves and short game matter to you, and you counterloop often, as these are the biggest strengths of this rubber.

    So basically, the Orange Sponge is the safe alternative for most amateurs out there, and the Provincial Blue Sponge is the advanced version of that, and it will be for the same players as the boosted Hurricane 3 Neo blue sponge but without boosting it and with less speed and spin overall, but a much better price.

    And for the Battle 2 Neo, to be fair, Tony and I struggle to see who to recommend it to. If you love counterlooping and like to smack every ball with full commitment, you may enjoy it, but even then, the Orange Sponge gives you similar speed with much more spin, control and balance, so in our opinion the Orange Sponge can easily take the place of the Neo.

    Obviously, the reasons not to enjoy these rubbers are the opposite of what I mentioned above, which in this case is the typical list for Chinese hard tacky rubbers: if you are a tensor player, stay away, if you are a beginner, stay away, if you want catapult and have short and compact strokes, stay away, and if you don't like linear rubbers, stay away as well. And if you are already happy boosting your Hurricane 3 Neo and don't mind the hassle, I'd say there is little reason to switch, as nothing can substitute a well boosted Hurricane 3 Neo fine tuned to your own liking.

    Final thoughts

    It has been so much fun going down memory lane and playing with the Battle 2 like I did when I had just started my table tennis journey and I was a total noob (still am in many ways xD), and I'm really happy I got to test them again, but this time fully in-depth.

    For me, the Battle 2 is still an iconic rubber because it achieves something that very few other rubbers have achieved, and that is a no-boost Hurricane alternative for a fraction of the Provincial/National Hurricane price, with amazing durability and similar speed and spin. So I'm definitely keeping them on my test blades to play with them now and then, especially for those moments where I don't feel like boosting.

    So for the last thoughts I would tell you all that if you are an amateur, and you are struggling with the boosting process and wasting too many new rubbers on that, just get the Battle 2 and enjoy life. I wouldn't put the 39 on my backhand though, and I still prefer many other tensors or hybrids for the backhand, but for the forehand both the Orange Sponge and the classic Provincial Blue Sponge are a pleasure to play with, just remember that the Orange Sponge is the easier of the two to use, especially if you are not the youngest person anymore like me ;)

    That was my review of the Friendship 729 Battle 2 Orange Sponge, Provincial Blue Sponge and Neo. I hope you enjoyed going back to the past with me, until my next review, and see you at the table!

    #rubbers#Friendship 729#Battle 2#Battle 2 Neo#chinese rubber#budget rubber#unboosted#review

    Need personalized equipment advice?

    I can help you find the perfect blade and rubber setup for your playing style.

    More Articles

    Continue exploring equipment insights and guides.